Infrastructure, not trade barriers, hurting horticulture exports

Mint reports

High delivery costs, caused primarily by a fragmented supply chain, bad logistics, together with poor standards are hurting India’s horticulture exports much more than trade barriers, says a new report prepared by the World Bank for the agriculture ministry.

Despite producing 11% of the world’s vegetables and 15% of fruits at very competitive costs of about 53% and 63% of average global prices, India’s share in global fruits and vegetables trade has remained at only 1.7% and 0.5%, respectively.

Lead economist with the Bank Aditya Mattoo says, “India is paying a huge logistical tax on agricultural products. The inability to compete abroad today might lead to the inability to compete at home tomorrow. And in horticulture, subsidies are not even an issue.” India has been strongly protesting the multilateral trade negotiation rounds against the high domestic farm subsidies enjoyed in the Euro area, the US and Japan.

The report therefore argues for creation of an integrated and competitive supply chain for agriculture along with radical reform in transport, storage and distribution services before India opens up to foreign competition.

Protectionists in India never miss a chance to point out to high domestic subsidies in US - for at least two reasons. They say US has double standards - even though its they who are guilty of that, having thanked these very subsidies when in the pre-Green revolution days. They say the root of all agricultural woes lie in these subsidies - when there is a bigger problem right here. I am not justifying policies of US, EU or Japan. But I dont think protectionist arguments based on US subsidies aren't justified.